How to Tackle Being Overqualified When Applying for a New Job!

Ben Wheeler • June 4, 2018

If you have been in the job market on more than one occasion in your career, it is likely your application may have been rejected at some stage, for the reason of being ’overqualified’. This causes immense frustration, as all too often this judgement is made in seconds, based on false assumptions by the potential employer or hiring manager.

There are often several reasons why you would consider a lower level position. This might be a result of being burnt out in a previous position; the desire to achieve a work/life balance; returning to work after a parental break; or you just need a job.

Below are the top reasons job seekers’ applications are rejected for being ’overqualified’ and how to overcome them.

You will get bored

The role you have applied for is at a lower level than your previous positions and it just won’t be challenging enough for you…

This could be very well be the reason why you even applied! So, the hiring manager either thinks you just made a mistake or in most cases does not understand your motivations. The only way to address this is, head on. This could be in your cover letter/CV or interview. It will be a matter of informing whomever you need to, it is a genuine reason.

We can’t pay you enough

You have had some high-level roles and it is clear you will have earned a much higher salary…

The person short-listing thinks you can’t possibly know how much this role is paying as you would not have applied. They have made a big assumption you will not ’meet the market’ rate for such a position and will be basing your salary expectations on your experience, which they can’t afford. Make it obvious you are completely flexible about salary and you will ’meet the market’ for the role.

You have more experience than the Manager

Awkward.

Well it shouldn’t be, they could choose to see it as a positive. You will be able to draw on this experience to add-value to your employer, but there is a chance the line manager could feel threatened. Again, you will need to convey your motivations but also you will have to placate this line manager. Think about it from their perspective and turn it into a positive.

You are only taking this until something better comes around

This scenario often applies to those who have recently found themselves out of work. It can be a very difficult position to be in as employers think you will be using them as a ’stop gap’.

Is this just a ’re-bound job’? Let them know you are fully aware of the job and believe it is a great long-term fit for you.

You won’t be ’hands-on’

If your CV gives a high-level summary of strategic goals you achieved, it is unlikely to give the vibe of someone that is ’hands-on’. This is often used to reject applicants and some candidates can find it very hard to convince the employer they can be a ’doer’.

Break down the smaller parts of any projects or responsibilities to demonstrate you have not just been ‘over-seeing’ and mention the relevant skills for the role to which you have applied.

Finally, make sure you are always positive and enthusiastic about your job applications. It goes a long way!

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia   I   United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.



Share insights

Recent articles

By Kalinda Campbell August 7, 2025
In this legal market update, industry leaders Emma Elliott and Damian Gordon join Kalinda Campbell to explore the top pressures and opportunities shaping legal practice in 2025. From salary trends to generational shifts, they share actionable insights on how firms across Australia and New Zealand are adapting.
By Kalinda Campbell August 4, 2025
Australia's legal sector enters 2025 with high demand for experienced lawyers and legal support staff, but limited supply. Law firms are expanding, yet many remain under-resourced. This update explores the pressures driving recruitment, the role of flexible work, and what firms must offer to stand out in a tight hiring market.
By Bianca Luck July 31, 2025
Across Australia and New Zealand, finance leaders are balancing automation, flexibility, and rising pay demands. In this joint update, Leanne Allen and Chris Yam share how stable teams, upskilling, and strategic roles are redefining accounting and finance for 2025.
By Liz Punshon July 28, 2025
Australia's labour market in 2025 is marked by rising applications, fewer job vacancies, and growing uncertainty for both employers and job seekers. While it may appear to be an employer's market, challenges like irrelevant applications and low candidate reliability persist. This update breaks down the state-level trends and strategic responses shaping recruitment.
By Aiden Boast July 24, 2025
With AI reshaping content and remote teams on the rise, the marketing world is in flux. In this update, Nicole Clarke explains how marketers can stay ahead by mastering new tools, preserving quality, and adapting quickly. Discover what it takes to lead in the age of automation.

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us