Why Didn’t I Get the Job?

Sally Horwood • May 7, 2018

Searching for a job is one of the greatest tests of one’s resilience. Getting rejection calls, emails, or hearing nothing at all happens to everyone, and for some of us, its months before we land the right job.

Not getting feedback is frustrating because you don’t know what went wrong, and how you can improve your chances. Below are some potential reasons you didn’t get the job at different stages during the application process.

Reasons You Did Not Get Selected for an Interview:

  • Were you qualified for the job? Generally in job ads there will be a few key criteria that are nonnegotiable. Previous experience in a similar role, industry exposure and relevant systems are often required. Businesses might not always have the capacity to invest large amounts of time into training, so read the ad properly and apply only to those that suit your skillset – saves you time too!
  • Was your application accurate and complete? The amount of time we receive incomplete or incorrect resumes is laughable. My colleague Colleen even wrote a blog about all the documents that were submitted instead of resumes! You’ve got a short window to impress, so make sure your experience is displayed clearly and in a comprehensible manner.
  • Did you demonstrate your skills clearly during the phone screen? If you’ve gotten a phone call, it means we like what we see. Ensure you are available to talk, and if you can’t call back later. Be prepared to give us more details about the work you have done and speak clearly and confidently.

Reasons You Did Not Get Selected After an Interview:

  • Were you prepared for the interview? One of the benefits of going through a recruiter is the help we can provide in prepping you for an interview. We coordinate and conduct hundreds of interviews each year, and we will have insight into what the organisation is specifically looking for – so when we want to help prepare you, take notes! Being late, or too early, not dressing to impress, and failing to do your research on the company will all put you at a disadvantage. First impressions mean a lot!
  • Did you demonstrate your experience properly? Prepare for the interview by identifying specific examples that demonstrate your skills so that if someone asks you ‘Tell me about a time where you..’ you can provide a well thought out, detailed example for them. Ensure you have questions to ask the interviewer as well. It’s these simple things that can make a candidate standout.
  • Did you build a positive rapport with the interviewer(s)? Nerves, tiredness, and interview fatigue can all impact how you build rapport with someone. It is often subconscious, but your perceived ‘cultural fit’ with the interviewer and the business is the main reason one candidate is picked over another.

Rejection happens, you can put your best foot forward and still get beaten by someone else. But rejection is often good, because if the company didn’t think you were the best candidate, then it may not have been the best fit for you in the long run. Just ensure that you try your best in each interview and demonstrate what a fantastic asset you are – you will find your dream job eventually!

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia   I   United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.



Share insights

Recent articles

By Leanne Lazarus September 22, 2025
Discover how AI is transforming HR in Australia. Explore risks, legal challenges, and opportunities for HR leaders to adapt and thrive in 2025.
By Liz Punshon September 11, 2025
Brooke Lord and Guy Davy join Liz Punshon to explore how Australia’s job market is recalibrating in 2025. They discuss internal mobility, AI integration, and the critical importance of adaptability in a market moving from volume to value.
By Kalinda Campbell September 9, 2025
Kalinda Campbell leads a deep dive into the legal landscape with Damian Gordon and Emma Elliott. They unpack how law firms are using flexibility, leadership development, and tech adoption to retain talent and future-proof their practices across Australia and New Zealand.
By Bianca Luck September 4, 2025
Leanne Allen and Chris Yam join Bianca Luck to explore the future of finance in 2025. They examine how teams are balancing stability with innovation, why upskilling beats offshoring, and how finance professionals are being asked to become both analysts and storytellers.
By Aiden Boast September 2, 2025
Nicole Clarke and Karl Sullivan join Aiden Boast to explore the future of marketing in 2025. From AI and predictive analytics to immersive tech and human storytelling, they unpack what it takes to build a modern, high-performing marketing team across Australia and New Zealand.

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us