Hiring Managers | How you can save time shortlisting in the current climate!

Kim Padmore • August 23, 2020

Have you experienced a longer lead time to fill job vacancies?

Our recent COVID Impact Report highlighted that even though 55% of Australian employers had to freeze their recruitment, the balance were still actively recruiting and employers noticed time to fill roles had increased.

Why is it taking longer?

On one hand, this is due to job seeker hesitancy across particular sectors, with 38% of job seekers admitting they are reluctant to make a career move until the current climate improves.

In other instances, employers have been inundated with applications. In my state of Western Australia, unemployment rates reaching 8.7% in June 2020 according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics. Whist volumes of applications have increased, the quality of job seekers who meet the criteria has not, resulting in hiring managers needing to invest more time to review and shortlist. Many of the hiring managers we work with, have shared with us, that they are receiving more unsuitable applications than ever, partly due to job seekers who appear to be applying, purely to meet their Job Seeker requirements.

How you can save time

Here are just a few ways you can save yourself time in your shortlisting process, to focus on the best people who will meet what you are looking for:

Clear, specific criteria

Firstly, make sure your criteria for suitable candidates is clearly spelt out and is not subjective. Be as specific as possible, for instance “must have experience creating pivot tables and using macros” rather than just “confident using Microsoft Excel”. This is where you want candidates to rule themselves out rather than in.

At the time of writing (August 2020), there are 201 live job ads on SEEK in Perth, which include “must be well presented”. I don’t believe there are many people that would read that and think to themselves “no, that’s not me, I won’t apply!”

Give candidates a task

Include an instruction in your job ad so you can see who has taken the time to actually read your ad and put in the effort. It could be as simple as to “call to introduce yourself.” This is especially helpful if they will be in a client-facing/customer service role. You can then reject the applications which haven’t followed through with your request and I guarantee you will save time!

Phone screen

Create some questions to ask during a phone screen that will help you rule out applications quickly. Ask them what attracted them to apply for the vacant role. If the response is that they can’t remember which job you are referring to, I’d be ruling them out then and there! You can also hone in on the competencies set out in the job advertisement, to ensure they meet the minimum requirements.

If you are an employer in Perth looking for advice or recruitment assistance, please don’t hesitate to call me on 08 6160 6201 or email me at kim@people2people.com.au

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia   I   United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.



Share insights

Recent articles

By Liz Punshon September 11, 2025
Brooke Lord and Guy Davy join Liz Punshon to explore how Australia’s job market is recalibrating in 2025. They discuss internal mobility, AI integration, and the critical importance of adaptability in a market moving from volume to value.
By Kalinda Campbell September 9, 2025
Kalinda Campbell leads a deep dive into the legal landscape with Damian Gordon and Emma Elliott. They unpack how law firms are using flexibility, leadership development, and tech adoption to retain talent and future-proof their practices across Australia and New Zealand.
By Bianca Luck September 4, 2025
Leanne Allen and Chris Yam join Bianca Luck to explore the future of finance in 2025. They examine how teams are balancing stability with innovation, why upskilling beats offshoring, and how finance professionals are being asked to become both analysts and storytellers.
By Aiden Boast September 2, 2025
Nicole Clarke and Karl Sullivan join Aiden Boast to explore the future of marketing in 2025. From AI and predictive analytics to immersive tech and human storytelling, they unpack what it takes to build a modern, high-performing marketing team across Australia and New Zealand.
By Leanne Lazarus August 28, 2025
Leanne Lazarus is joined by Adeline Rooney and Samantha McCall to explore how HR teams across Australia and New Zealand are embracing personalisation, AI, and employee-centred strategies. From microlearning to remote workforce tools, they unpack what’s redefining success in 2025.

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us