You Can Stay Here…but Only If We Can Exploit You First

Lisa Johnson • October 26, 2016

Sometimes I have the opportunity to have interesting conversations with people who think very differently than I do. OK, these conversations don’t tend to go too well. I am not known for keeping my opinions to myself and I have, on more than one occasion, told someone they are just plain ignorant and possibly stupid. But I will admit when I am wrong and I will apologise if someone is hurt by my comments, so I am not all that bad! One conversation that can get me completely riled up is one that starts with “they take all our jobs” statement. I can go straight to ‘defcon 5’ on this one. Because what jobs are they talking about? The fruit picking jobs out in the regional areas of Australia that the backpackers do to earn their second year visa?

Where it appears, some have been badly ripped off and exploited? Are these jobs available because ‘Aussies’ have said “you can bugger off, I am not working in 40 degree heat with one bottle of water for no money; I would rather be on the dole?” Rightly so, because no one should be asked to work under those conditions. Do we honestly ask visitors to our country to work under difficult conditions, with the possibility they could be exploited, by holding out the second year visa carrot? What kind of country are we to do things like that to people? What is wrong with our visa system that people could possibly be exploited, just so they can stay a little longer?

We employ a lot of people on working holiday visas. It’s not terribly unusual for a temp on a working holiday visa (417 or 462) to work for an Australian employer for 6 months straight, and we quickly find them other work when they want it.

The working holiday visa is supposed to be for people who come here to travel around the country as a tourist, and working holiday makers (WHM’s) certainly do this, but they also work to fund their travels. And some of them work quite a lot. I cannot tell you how many people come here on their WHM visa and who find work really quickly.

Those with previous office experience in their home country are often snapped up within days of hitting our shores. They are not pretentious, they generally work hard and are reliable and they love our lifestyle. When summer comes and a cashed up WHM finds themselves at the Opera Bar in Sydney with the breeze rifling through their hair and cold champagne in hand...you may just see tears of joy in their eyes and a resolution to stay as long as they can; because THIS is the life! And to let them stay we make them work in jobs where they could be exploited. Oh the shame

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia   I   United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.



Share insights

Recent articles

By people2people December 20, 2025
Skills-first hiring is gaining momentum, with 85% of organisations now using it in some form. However, challenges around assessment, training and leadership alignment continue to limit consistent adoption. Explore what’s driving the shift and how employers can make skills-based hiring work in practice.
By Aiden Boast December 14, 2025
Australia’s latest Wage Price Index shows wage growth steady at 0.8% for the September 2025 quarter and 3.4% annually. Explore what this means for real wages, labour market conditions, and employer planning for 2026.
By Aiden Boast December 7, 2025
A detailed breakdown of Australia’s 2025 employment landscape, exploring hiring trends, AI’s impact on job search and recruitment, shifting candidate expectations, and strategic insights to help employers prepare for 2026.
By Leanne Lazarus December 1, 2025
A comprehensive look at how Australia’s 2025 workplace legislation shaped HR practices, covering wage theft, sexual harassment reforms, psychosocial risks and the right to disconnect, with insights to prepare for 2026.
By Liz Punshon November 23, 2025
Explore why burnout is rising across Australia, the workplace factors driving it and what leaders can do to support wellbeing, reduce stress and create healthier work environments.

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us