Ranting and Raving

Mark Smith • October 2, 2016

Before putting pen to paper (or finger to keyboard), I normally have a specific purpose or message that I think is worth sharing on the internet. Today, I have not spent any time with research but instead I am going to have a bit of a rant about an extraordinarily disappointing experience I had yesterday. Like most recruitment firms, people2people is always on the lookout for experienced recruitment consultants wanting to make a change and join our team. This week, I received a call in response to one of the campaigns that p2p has run across various platforms.

The potential consultant, let’s call her Jane for the sake of this blog, called through, introduced herself and asked “If the job was still available?” Not an unusual question, but pretty naïve given that I subsequently found out that Jane had twenty years’ experience within the recruitment industry! After establishing it was the advertised recruitment consultant’s position, I asked Jane a few questions about her background and she was a little vague, but determined.

She had twenty years’ experience and was a part owner in a recruitment firm, which sounded pretty good. Unfortunately, Jane went on to tell me that things hadn’t gone well with her husband and she was looking for a new role. Too much information 45 seconds into a call with a potential employer! Remember this is someone with twenty years’ experience. All that experience is pretty hard to ignore, so I suggested that we meet and talk through what she would be looking for given it was a big change in her life. We agreed a time and I then asked for her resume.

She didn’t have one! Twenty years’ experience and no CV! OK, not good, but possibly understandable, so I compromised again and said that I could use her LinkedIn profile. Her profile had a profile picture which was clearly a selfie taken in her car. Not exactly corporate, but also not a deal breaker. To confirm the interview, I said I would send her an email, so I asked for her email address, which turned out to be a comical play on words. Hmmmmm After waiting ten minutes after the scheduled interview time, I decided to call Jane to see if she was still attending our interview.

She answered! Jane had forgotten about the meeting we had arranged less than 24 hours before. “I simply have forgotten….. actually I had a family emergency.” Frankly, I was pretty annoyed given the occurrences leading up to our interview, so I cancelled the meeting and said I didn’t like having my time wasted. Jane then told me not to lecture her “F$%k off” and hung up the phone. So what have I learned from this experience;

  • If someone hasn’t read the advertisement and they are responding to an ad, then you may have a problem

  • Someone looking for a new role without a CV is also not a good indicator

  • Linkedin profiles are a public reflection of you and your personality.

  • Comical email addresses are best kept for friends, not potential employers.

  • Turn up if you say you are going to.

  • Don’t lie about why you didn’t turn up

  • Accept advice without swearing and hanging up the phone

Finally and probably the most disappointing, is that Jane has been in the recruitment industry for twenty years. A sad indictment of an industry that I have a particular passion for. Needless to say, there is probably a very good reason Jane is looking for a new role and I think I may have dodged a bullet. Rant over.

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia   I   United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.



Share insights

Recent articles

By Aiden Boast November 9, 2025
Aiden Boast, North Shore Manager, explores new research revealing Australians’ growing unease toward artificial intelligence. From job fears to creativity concerns, this analysis unpacks the “national tension” shaping Australia’s future with AI.
By Aiden Boast November 2, 2025
Explore how Australian businesses can strengthen inclusion and innovation through neuroinclusion. Learn from Aisling Smith and Aiden Boast about creating workplaces that support neurodivergent employees and unlock their full potential.
By Leanne Lazarus October 26, 2025
Discover how leadership development is evolving in 2025. Learn what organisations can do to build interdependent, future-ready leaders who drive performance, collaboration, and culture.
By Peta Seaman October 19, 2025
Australia’s job vacancies fell by 2.7% in August 2025, signalling a shift toward more balanced hiring conditions. people2people’s Peta Seaman explores what this means for employers and job seekers across the country.
By Peta Seaman October 12, 2025
Discover how fear of failure is shaping Australian workplaces in 2025 — and learn practical ways employees and employers can overcome it to build confidence, creativity, and long-term success.

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us