When a Recruiter Calls YOU: How to Make a Good First Impression

Sally Horwood • July 19, 2015

If a recruiter calls you, the interview process has already begun. Often candidates don't realise this, and a bad first impression on the phone is the biggest causal factor in you failing to secure an interview. Below are some tips to ensure you wow your recruiter into a face-to-face interview.

Answering the phone

As soon as you start applying for jobs, be prepared for recruiters to call you. This means answering in a clear and professional manner and only answering when you're free to do so. If you're at work or on public transport, don't answer, and call back when you are prepared.

Be prepared

Nothing sounds worse than when a recruiter calls about a role and the candidate clearly doesn't know which role they are referring to. Print off a list of the roles and responsibilities of those roles that you've applied for, and carry them with you at all times. It is difficult to remember all the positions you've applied for, but knowing the responsibilities and what motivated you to apply can make a world of difference.

Answering questions

Refer to the consultant by their name – it shows that you're listening – and answer with certainty. Know what you want when you apply; saying that you're 'happy to work anywhere' or 'don't mind about salary' isn't true, and recruiters know that. Bills have to be paid, and of course candidates think they'd be willing to travel anywhere for the perfect role, but if the role means driving over an hour with traffic, it stops being 'perfect' very quickly.

Demonstrate flexibility

Be available for interviews. Understandably, candidates may have work, but be available before and after hours or during lunch time. The recruiter will be calling several people for the same role, and a candidate will look far more appealing if they are flexible, compared to someone who doesn't appear to be trying to secure an interview.

Finally, show enthusiasm

Recruiters are very busy, so place the onus on yourself to call them and keep yourself in the know of how your application is going. The bottom line for doing well on the phone is to be prepared. If you want to secure a new role, show your motivation by knowing what you've applied for, answering the phone and questions clearly and confidently, and be flexible for future interviews!

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia   I   United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.



Share insights

Recent articles

By Aiden Boast July 14, 2025
As the marketing and digital industry heads into 2025, teams are balancing cautious hiring with growing expectations for innovation and versatility. AI adoption is high, yet resource shortages persist. This update highlights the sector's shift toward cross-functional talent and how organisations are redefining roles to stay ahead.
By Nicole Consterdine July 10, 2025
Australia’s public sector is navigating budget pressures, skills shortages, and slow hiring cycles while striving to retain staff in a competitive landscape. In this update, Chelsea Dale discusses where the biggest recruitment roadblocks and opportunities lie. Discover what agencies can do to future-proof their team
By Nicole Consterdine July 7, 2025
The public sector in Australia and New Zealand is under increasing strain as budget cuts, slow hiring, and talent attrition challenge workforce stability. While most recruitment is aimed at maintaining existing operations, long-term strategies are falling behind. This update explores the pressures shaping government teams and the steps needed to secure future capability.
By Mary Savova July 7, 2025
New legal reforms in Australia and New Zealand are transforming employment practices in 2025. From fixed-term contract limits to stronger protections against harassment and wage theft, the pressure is on employers to modernise policies. This update explains what’s changed and how businesses can build compliance and trust.
By Sharna Bryant July 3, 2025
Australia’s sales job market is holding steady, even as economic pressures shape new candidate behaviours and expectations. In this update, SEEK’s Danny Merrigan reveals why salary review conversations now top the list of priorities and which roles are driving hiring activity. Learn what’s shaping recruitment success

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us