Ten Reasons Why You SHOULD Tell Your Recruiter Your Current Salary

Mark Smith • May 18, 2015

I stumbled upon an article today on the Forbes website titled ' Your Salary History is Nobody’s Business.' Normally Forbes is a great source of content, and I often tweet their stories. Unfortunately, on this occasion, I would have to totally disagree with the author, and, as she says in the article, I am 'hissing' my objections to her advice. So here are ten reasons why you should share your current salary with your agency recruiter.

1. Your recruiter is your advocate and wants to get you a new role.

Just like in the movie Jerry Maguire, your recruiter is wanting to work with you. To secure your new role, it is best to understand your current situation, including your current salary.

2. Your salary is a package and not just cash.

Your recruiter discusses salaries every day. They have access to tools such as people2people's salarysiite to understand the market. Although you can do some research on the internet, understanding the market is difficult. Remember that your salary package is more than just cash. Many people are exposed to benefits without understanding what those benefits really entail. A good example of this is parking. Working outside a CBD, parking may be provided, yet in a CBD, it's definitely a benefit. Do you know what your current salary package is really worth?

3. You may be extremely well paid in your current role and not know it.

When considering a move, you should also consider how good you actually have it. I know that in the past I have actually given advice to candidates that they should stay with the current employer based on their salary package and career prospects, as the market at that time would not be able to match or even improve on those benefits.

4. You may be extremely underpaid in your current role and not know it.

Your expectations for a new role may be too low! Hard to believe, but, once again, without using your recruiter's market knowledge, how would you know?

5. Your recruiter is an expert and discusses salaries every day.

Reading the Forbes article, you would think that doing a little research online is enough to understand the market. Sure, you should do some research, but your recruiter discusses and negotiates salaries every working day. You should tap into this knowledge. Knowing how your current salary stacks up in this market is a very important part of securing a new role, whether it's with your recruiter or through other sources.

6. Recruitment is a free service for candidates.

Remember that the recruiter has no obligation to assist with your job search. Not sharing key information may lead the recruiter to decide not to work with you.

7. Trust

Your career is important. Working with a recruiter to assist with your next career move means having confidence and trust in your recruiter. Trust is reciprocal, so withholding information doesn't lend itself to building a mutually beneficial and strong relationship.

8. The recruiter doesn't control the market for salaries.

The premise of the Forbes article is that withholding your current salary package details is part of negotiating your next salary package. I disagree with this. The recruiter needs full sight of your current circumstances to advise you correctly. The recruiter does not control how much the market will pay. They are normally briefed on a salary range and then should discuss with you the salary for which you would like to be represented for the role.

9. Your salary is not your worth as a person but a reflection of the tasks you undertake.

It seems logical, but all of us at one point have thought, 'I am worth more than that,' when thinking about our salary package. The reality is that your salary reflects the role you are undertaking. If you are a neurosurgeon accepting a data entry role, then you will be paid for undertaking the data entry role. So when considering your current salary, it should be considered alongside a conversation about the role you are currently undertaking. Your recruiter obtains details about roles every day, not just looking at a job title which you may find on sites such as PayScale. Use this knowledge. Share your current salary details and then benchmark.

10. What advantage is there in keeping your current salary a secret?

Finally, I am still struggling to understand what advantage there is in keeping your current salary a secret. It may very well be your business, but what exact advantage do you gain by keeping quiet on the details? I can't see any.

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia   I   United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.



Share insights

Recent articles

By Peta Seaman June 26, 2025
South Australia's property sector faced one of its most disruptive years in recent history, with sweeping legal reforms, economic pressures, and shifting tenant and investor behaviours. In this update, industry leaders explore how agencies adapted to short-notice legislation, rising vacancies, and new buyer demographic
By Peta Seaman June 23, 2025
The property and real estate industry is navigating a complex 2025, with rising reliance on AI and persistent staffing gaps. While growth plans are in place, companies face challenges in recruiting key talent and adapting benefits strategies. This update explores how the sector is balancing optimism with operational pressure and what employers are doing to stay ahead.
By Sharna Bryant June 18, 2025
Discover the latest developments in Australia’s sales sector, where AI integration and talent acquisition are reshaping the industry. With expansion plans underway and evolving skills in demand, this update explores how companies are navigating recruitment challenges and preparing for 2025. Learn which roles are most in demand, what benefits are attracting top talent, and how businesses are responding to ongoing turnover.
By Colleen Deere June 11, 2025
Australia has made intentional wage theft a criminal offence, with tough new penalties now in force. In this blog, we break down what the changes mean, common employer mistakes, and how to stay compliant in 2025. Featuring expert insights from Antonino Meduri of AM Law & Partners, it's essential reading for business owners, HR professionals, and payroll teams navigating the new Fair Work landscape.
Explore the legal and ethical essentials of managing redundancies in Australia. Featuring expert ins
By Leanne Lazarus June 10, 2025
Explore the legal and ethical essentials of managing redundancies in Australia. Featuring expert insights from employment law and HR specialists, this blog outlines the key obligations, common pitfalls, and practical steps for handling role changes with compliance and care. Ideal for HR leaders and employers navigating workforce change.

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us